Notice: Function _load_textdomain_just_in_time was called incorrectly. Translation loading for the acf domain was triggered too early. This is usually an indicator for some code in the plugin or theme running too early. Translations should be loaded at the init action or later. Please see Debugging in WordPress for more information. (This message was added in version 6.7.0.) in /var/www/vhosts/brixon.ai/httpdocs/wp-includes/functions.php on line 6121

Notice: Function _load_textdomain_just_in_time was called incorrectly. Translation loading for the borlabs-cookie domain was triggered too early. This is usually an indicator for some code in the plugin or theme running too early. Translations should be loaded at the init action or later. Please see Debugging in WordPress for more information. (This message was added in version 6.7.0.) in /var/www/vhosts/brixon.ai/httpdocs/wp-includes/functions.php on line 6121
Digitizing Signatures: AI Verifies Authenticity and Authorization – Brixon AI

Why Traditional Signature Processes Slow Down Your Business

Sound familiar? Your project manager has been waiting three days for a signed power of attorney. The client is ready to kick off the €250,000 project—yet the paperwork is lost somewhere between reception, management, and accounting.

Scenarios like these cost German businesses millions every day. A 2024 study by Bitkom e.V. found that media breaks in signature processes cause an average delay of 2.3 days per transaction.

The problem goes deeper than you think. Its not just about the time spent printing, signing, and scanning documents.

The Hidden Costs of Paper-Based Signatures

In a mid-sized company with 150 employees, there are about 40 documents requiring signatures every day. It quickly adds up:

Process Step Time Spent Involved Persons Cost per Transaction
Print document 3 minutes Clerk €2.50
Route for signature 8 minutes Clerk + Manager €12.00
Signature and return 5 minutes Manager €6.25
Scan and archive 4 minutes Clerk €3.33
Total per transaction 20 minutes €24.08

With 40 such transactions a day, thats €963—every single day. Over the course of a year, more than €200,000 is spent just on internal processing.

And thats just the beginning.

Compliance Risks in Manual Signature Verification

Who actually checks the authenticity of a signature? In most companies, its trusted to the trained eye of the clerk.

The issue: People detect signature forgeries in only 60–70% of cases. For critical authorizations or contracts, thats a significant risk.

Especially problematic for:

  • Powers of attorney for banking or real estate transactions
  • Employment contracts with special authorities
  • Compliance-relevant documents
  • High-value contracts

One missed fraud case can quickly result in six-figure losses.

The Media Break Effect: Where Efficiency Is Lost

Imagine: your digital workflow is seamless—right up until the signature. Suddenly, data leaves the system, gets printed, signed, scanned, and fed back in.

These media breaks (the shift between digital and paper formats) are efficiency killers. They cause not only delays, but also errors:

  • Unreadable scans due to poor scan quality
  • Lost documents in the paper process
  • Inconsistent archiving and version control
  • Manual entry errors when transferring back into digital systems

This is where modern AI-based signature solutions come into play.

How AI-Powered Signature Recognition Works

Modern AI does much more than just identify pictures of cats. In signature authentication, several smart systems work together—like a digital handwriting expert who never gets tired.

But how does it actually work?

Biometric Signature Analysis: The Digital Fingerprint

Every signature is unique—not just visually, but in the way it’s produced. AI systems analyze over 100 different parameters:

  • Static features: shape, size, proportions of letters
  • Dynamic features: writing speed, pressure pattern, pause times
  • Behavioral parameters: pen grip, writing rhythm, acceleration behavior

For example: When Thomas, our engineering CEO, signs his name, the system doesnt just capture the visible letters. It also records that he always pauses for 0.3 seconds on his T and always finishes his s with a distinctive drop in pressure.

These biometric patterns are virtually impossible to forge.

Deep Learning for Signature Recognition

The core of modern systems is neural networks trained on millions of signature samples. These deep learning algorithms (complex AI models that detect patterns in large datasets) work similarly to the human brain—but with far greater precision.

This is how training works:

  1. Data collection: Genuine signatures are captured under a variety of conditions
  2. Pattern analysis: The system learns which variations are still considered authentic
  3. Forgery detection: Training with known forgery attempts
  4. Continuous optimization: The system keeps learning from every new signature

The result: accuracy rates of more than 99.5%—far better than any human verification.

AI-Based Power of Attorney Verification: Beyond Signature Checking

This is where things get really interesting. Advanced AI systems don’t just check if a signature is genuine—they understand context.

Imagine: An employee wants to sign a power of attorney for €50,000. The system automatically checks:

  • Is this person even authorized to issue such powers of attorney?
  • Does the amount comply with internal guidelines?
  • Are all required supporting details present?
  • Has dual-control (four-eyes principle) been enforced?

This intelligent verification pairs signature authentication with compliance checks. The outcome: automatic approval for valid powers of attorney, instant warnings for irregularities.

OCR and NLP: When AI Understands Content

Modern systems can do more than just read signatures—they can comprehend the entire document. Two more AI technologies are involved:

OCR (Optical Character Recognition) digitizes handwritten or printed content, converting it into editable text. The AI can recognize even badly written handwriting with over 95% accuracy.

NLP (Natural Language Processing) analyzes document content semantically. The system identifies whether it’s a contract, a power of attorney, or an invoice, and checks for logical consistency.

Real-world example: When a lease agreement is signed, the system automatically checks if tenants and landlords are correctly named, the rental amount is plausible, and all legally required clauses are present.

Blockchain Integration: Immutable Proof

For maximum security, leading providers integrate blockchain technology. Every verified signature is stored as an immutable digital fingerprint (hash) on the blockchain.

This means: even years later, you can irrefutably prove a signature was genuine at time X, and that the document has not been altered since.

This is particularly important for:

  • Long-term contract archiving
  • Compliance evidence for regulators
  • Court cases
  • International business transactions

The technology is available. But how do you use it in a legally compliant way?

Legally Compliant Digital Signatures: What You Need to Know

This is where the wheat is separated from the chaff. Technically, a lot is possible—but not everything is legally permitted.

The good news: Germany’s lawmakers have already paved the way for digital signatures. Since 2016, the EUs eIDAS Regulation (Electronic Identification, Authentication and Trust Services) provides the legal foundation.

But beware: not every digital signature is automatically legally valid.

The Three Levels of Digital Signatures under eIDAS

European law distinguishes between three security levels. Depending on your use case, different standards apply:

Level Name Security Level Typical Use Legal Effect
1 Simple Electronic Signature (SES) Basic Email signatures, internal approvals Limited validity
2 Advanced Electronic Signature (AES) Moderate Business contracts, HR documents Fully legally valid
3 Qualified Electronic Signature (QES) High Notarized deeds, government communication Equivalent to handwritten

For most corporate processes, the Advanced Electronic Signature (AES) is sufficient. It provides the best balance between security and practicality.

AI Signature Verification and Evidentiary Value in Court

Here’s the key question: Are AI-verified signatures accepted in court?

The answer is yes—provided certain requirements are met. What counts is thorough documentation of the verification process. The system must be able to demonstrate:

  • Which algorithms were used for verification
  • The training data used by the system
  • The detection accuracy for similar cases
  • What security measures were in place to prevent tampering

For you, this means: Choose only providers who meet these documentation standards.

GDPR-Compliant Signature Processes

Biometric data (and signatures are included) are subject to strict privacy laws under the GDPR:

Explicit Consent: Individuals must actively consent to biometric analysis of their signature. Hiding it in the T&Cs isn’t enough.

Purpose Limitation: Data may only be used for the agreed purpose. A signature for an employment contract can’t suddenly be analyzed for marketing purposes.

Storage Limitation: Biometric data must be deleted once its purpose is fulfilled. For contracts with a ten-year retention period, biometric features must still be anonymized after a reasonable time.

Technical Security: Data must be protected using state-of-the-art encryption. End-to-end encryption and zero-knowledge architectures are now standard.

Sector-Specific Compliance Requirements

Depending on your industry, additional rules may apply. Examples include:

Financial services: BaFin requires a qualified timestamp and audit-proof archiving under GoBD (German accounting standards).

Healthcare: Patient data is subject to strict regulations. Signatures on treatment agreements must be secured with medical-grade encryption (ISO 27799).

Public sector clients: EU procurement directives apply to tenders. Digital signatures must be issued via accredited trust service providers.

Export control: Companies subject to ITAR or EAR must ensure signature data doesn’t get transferred to third countries.

International Recognition: When Borders Don’t Matter

Does your company operate internationally? Make sure digital signatures are recognized in your target country.

eIDAS covers the EU. Elsewhere, different standards apply:

  • USA: Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act (ESIGN Act)
  • Switzerland: Federal Act on Electronic Signatures (ZertES)
  • Singapore: Electronic Transactions Act
  • Brazil: Medida Provisória 2.200-2/2001

Leading providers offer multi-standard compliance. The system automatically determines which standard applies and enacts the appropriate safeguards for each signature.

This saves legal headaches and makes international business much easier.

Implement Secure Digital Signature Processes without Media Disruption

Theory is one thing—practice is another. Here’s how to implement AI-based signature processes that actually work.

Without overwhelming your staff or IT department in the process.

Step 1: Review Your Current Signature Processes

Before introducing new technology, you need to understand what’s already in place. A systematic analysis often leads to surprising discoveries.

Start with these core questions:

  • Which documents actually require signatures?
  • Who is authorized to sign (authorization matrix)?
  • How long do your current processes take?
  • Where do most delays occur?
  • What legal requirements apply to each document type?

A proven approach: Have each signature transaction recorded for one week, including time stamp and involved parties.

The outcome may surprise you. Most companies discover 20–30% of signature transactions are technically unnecessary.

Step 2: Integrate into Existing Systems

This is often where projects fail—not due to the technology itself, but the lack of integration.

Modern AI signature solutions cannot be used in isolation. They must be seamlessly integrated with your IT ecosystem:

System Category Typical Systems Integration Via Benefit
ERP Systems SAP, Microsoft Dynamics, Sage REST APIs Automated document creation
DMS/ECM SharePoint, OpenText, Alfresco WebDAV, CMIS Automated archiving
HR Systems Personio, BambooHR, Workday SCIM, LDAP Automated authorization checks
CRM Systems Salesforce, HubSpot, Pipedrive Webhooks Automated contract release

Integration should be bidirectional: the signature system pulls data from your source systems and writes results back automatically.

Example: A €10,000 order is created in your CRM. The system automatically generates the contract, selects the correct signatory based on your authorization matrix, and launches the digital signature process.

Once signed, the data flows back: CRM status changes to “contract signed,” the DMS archives the document in a legally compliant way, and the ERP system can release the invoice.

Step 3: Set Up Multi-Channel Signature Processes

Your business partners differ in their affinity for technology. While internal staff may embrace new tools, some clients still prefer traditional methods.

Intelligent systems therefore offer several signature channels:

Desktop/tablet signatures: Traditional signature on a graphics tablet that captures biometric data—ideal for office settings and meetings.

Mobile signatures: Sign on a smartphone or tablet—perfect for field staff or onsite appointments.

Remote signatures: Qualified electronic signatures via secure browser access—making signatures possible from home offices or international partners.

Hybrid processes: Combine a paper signature with an AI authenticity check—so even on paper, you can benefit from automated verification.

Step 4: User-Friendliness and Change Management

The best system is useless if your staff won’t use it. Successful implementation depends on pragmatic change management.

Proven strategies:

Create pilot groups: Roll out within tech-savvy departments first. Their positive experience will persuade skeptical colleagues more than any presentation.

Communicate quick wins: Highlight measurable improvements. “Thanks to the new solution, contract approvals are 60% faster” convinces every controller.

Hands-on training: Forget endless PowerPoint slides—use live demos with real business scenarios from employees’ daily work.

Set up a support hotline: There will be plenty of questions in the first weeks. Prompt, competent assistance prevents frustration and regression to old habits.

Step 5: Security Concept and Contingency Planning

What happens if the system fails? If hackers attack? If an employee loses their credentials?

A robust security concept covers all these scenarios:

  • Redundant systems: Critical signature processes run in parallel on multiple servers
  • Offline fallback: Defined analog backup process in case of emergency
  • Access control: Multi-factor authentication and role-based permissions
  • Audit trails: Every action logged and archived immutably
  • Disaster recovery: Automatic backups and defined restoration processes

Motto: Hope for the best, plan for the worst!

Step 6: Ongoing Optimization through AI Learning

Modern AI systems get better over time—but only when set up properly.

Enable these learning features:

Adaptive thresholds: The system continuously learns from both real and forged signatures, automatically optimizing detection algorithms.

Process improvement: AI identifies bottlenecks in your signature workflows and suggests improvements.

Anomaly detection: Unusual patterns (e.g., a surge in signatures at 2 a.m.) are flagged automatically.

Predictive analytics: The system predicts workloads and can allocate resources as required.

The result: A system that continuously adapts to your business processes and gets more efficient over time.

ROI of Digital Signature Processes: Measurable Efficiency Gains

Let’s talk numbers. At the end of the day, it’s not technical features that decide a project’s success, but the hard facts on the cost side.

The good news: Hardly any other digitalization measure delivers such a rapid ROI (Return on Investment) as automating signature processes.

Direct Savings: The Immediate Benefits

Let’s start with the obvious. A mid-sized company with 150 employees processes about 40 signature-required documents daily.

Cost comparison before and after digitalization:

Cost Item Paper Process (per year) Digital Process (per year) Savings
Personnel (processing) €156,000 €31,200 €124,800
Paper, printing, postage €8,400 €840 €7,560
Archiving €12,000 €2,400 €9,600
Compliance management €15,600 €4,680 €10,920
Total savings €192,000 €39,120 €152,880

You’ll incur one-off implementation costs of about €25,000 and annual license fees of €18,000.

The outcome: ROI over 300%—in just the first year.

Indirect Benefits: The Hidden Treasure

Major savings often occur where you least expect them. Faster signature processes shorten entire business cycles.

Sales example: Getting proposals and contracts signed three days sooner significantly shortens the sales cycle. For an average deal of €45,000 at 5% interest, that’s a financial benefit of about €18 per deal.

Doesn’t sound like much? For 200 deals a year, that’s already €3,600—just from the interest gain.

Procurement example: Faster vendor contracts mean better terms. Early orders often win quantity discounts or early-bird offers. Even just 0.5% better conditions on €2 million spend means €10,000 additional margin.

Project management example: In our engineering example, projects can wait days for signed authorizations. Each day’s delay on a €250,000 project costs about €850 (capital tie-up, staff expenses, opportunity cost).

With automated signature processes, projects start on average 2.3 days sooner. That’s €1,955 saved per project.

Risk Reduction: What Doesn’t Happen Also Saves Money

Signature forgeries are rare—but expensive. On average, each uncovered fraud case costs German companies €127,000.

Plus, there are unquantifiable losses:

  • Loss of reputation with clients and partners
  • Loss of trust among banks and investors
  • Regulatory fines for compliance breaches
  • Legal costs for litigation

AI-powered signature verification reduces fraud risk by over 95%. Even if you prevent only one fraud every five years, you’ll recoup your investment through this effect alone.

Scalability: When Growth Stops Hurting

This is the true benefit of smart automation. While paper-based processes scale linearly with business volume, digital processes remain virtually flat.

Example: Your business grows from 40 to 80 signature transactions daily. Paper-based processing costs would double. Digitally, costs rise by less than 20%.

This provides a sustainable competitive edge. While competitors scale up administration as they grow, you divert resources to value-adding activities instead.

ROI Calculation: Your Practice Check

Every company is different. Use this formula for your individual ROI calculation:

  1. Establish baseline: Track all signature processes for two weeks
  2. Quantify time investment: Multiply minutes by hourly wage for each involved person
  3. Add material costs: Paper, printing, postage, archiving
  4. Estimate opportunity costs: What deals are delayed by slow processes?
  5. Assess risk-related costs: What’s your potential loss per fraud case?

Most companies uncover savings exceeding their initial estimates by 40–60%.

Financing and Payback: Options for Any Budget

You don’t have to pay it all at once. Modern providers offer flexible financing models:

SaaS model: Monthly fees per user or transaction—ideal for Capex avoidance.

On-premise licenses: One-time purchase plus annual maintenance—cost-effective for high-volume, long-term users.

Hybrid approach: Combine cloud services for standard processes with on-premise installations for sensitive data.

Pay-per-use: Charges based on the number of processed signatures—perfect for companies with seasonal fluctuations.

Typical payback is between 8 and 18 months, depending on your process volume and implementation depth.

After that, the savings go straight to your bottom line. In our 150-employee example, that’s an extra €150,000 a year—every year.

Choosing the Right Solution: Decision-Makers’ Checklist

The market for digital signature solutions is overwhelming. More than 200 providers worldwide promise the perfect solution for your company.

But which one really fits your needs? This checklist will help you decide.

Technical Requirements: Laying the Foundation

Check these basics before diving into feature comparisons:

Criterion Minimum Requirement Recommendation Why Important?
AI Detection Rate 95% 99%+ Reduces false positives
Processing Speed < 5 seconds < 2 seconds Drives user acceptance
Concurrent users Current staff size 150% of current size Growth buffer
API availability REST API REST + GraphQL System integration
Offline capability Optional Recommended Reliability

Pro tip: During your demo, have real signatures from your company tested. Theoretical accuracy is one thing—performance with your specific signature styles is another.

Legal Compliance: Non-Negotiable

Every vendor claims “full legal compliance.” Ask about specifics:

  • eIDAS certification: Is there a current certification as a Qualified Trust Service Provider?
  • GDPR compliance: Where are biometric data processed, for how long, and when are they deleted?
  • Industry standards: Does the solution meet your sector’s specific requirements (BaFin, ISO 27001, etc.)?
  • Audit reports: Are up-to-date penetration tests and compliance audits available?
  • International standards: Which country-specific standards are supported?

Request written confirmation. In case of compliance issues, liability falls on your company—not the provider.

Integration and System Compatibility

The best technology is worthless if it doesn’t fit your IT landscape. Ask:

Existing systems: Which ERP, CRM, DMS systems are natively supported? Are prebuilt connectors available?

Single sign-on: Does it integrate with your identity management (Active Directory, Azure AD, etc.)?

Mobile support: How well does it work on smartphones and tablets? Are there native apps or is it browser-based?

Cloud vs on-premise: What deployment options are offered? Can you start hybrid and transition later?

File formats: Which input formats (PDF, TIFF, JPG) are supported? Which output formats are available?

Vendor Assessment: What Really Matters

The technology is important—but your long-term success depends on the partner behind it.

Market experience: How long has the provider been active? Who are their references? Are there customers in your sector?

Support quality: What support levels are offered? Is German-language support available? What are the response times?

Product roadmap & innovation: How is the technology developing? What new features are planned? How often are updates released?

Financial stability: Is the provider viable long-term? Startups are at greater risk of insolvency or takeover.

Training and consulting: Does the provider offer change management support? Are user trainings available?

Cost-Benefit Analysis: A True Comparison

Watch out for hidden costs. These items must be included in every complete calculation:

  • License fees: Per user, per signature, or flat rates?
  • Implementation: What does initial setup and customization cost?
  • Integration: Costs for connections to existing systems
  • Training: User training and change management
  • Support: Annual maintenance and premium support
  • Hardware: Need for tablets or special devices?
  • Compliance: Certification and audit fees

Always base your decision on a three-year total cost of ownership (TCO) calculation for realistic budgeting.

Proof of Concept: Test Before You Decide

Talk is silver, testing is gold. Every reputable provider should offer a proof of concept (PoC).

How to make your test meaningful:

  1. Realistic scenarios: Use actual documents and signatures from your organization
  2. Diverse user groups: Have both tech-savvy and skeptical staff try it
  3. Peak load test: Simulate your highest expected volume
  4. Failure simulation: What happens with connection outages or server failures?
  5. Integration test: Does it work with your critical systems?

Document every result systematically. This helps not only in vendor selection but also in later contract negotiations.

Contract Negotiation: What to Watch For

Your contract will dictate your flexibility for years to come. Put these items on your checklist:

Cancellation terms: How can you exit if the solution fails? 3–12 months’ notice is standard.

Data migration: What happens to your data at contract end? Are export functions available? Any extra fees?

SLA guarantees: What uptime is guaranteed? What if they fall short? Are penalties included?

Scalability: Can you adjust user licenses flexibly? Are there minimum quantities?

Updates and upgrades: Are these included? Who controls update timing?

Liability: Who’s liable for damages from detection errors or outages? Is there cyber insurance?

The Three Most Common Mistakes When Choosing a Provider

Learn from others’ mistakes:

Mistake 1: Focusing only on price. The cheapest solution is rarely the most cost-effective. Focus on total benefit—not just the initial price tag.

Mistake 2: Overcomplicating requirements. Many companies define hundreds of features they never use. Stay focused on your core processes.

Mistake 3: Excluding users from selection. IT decision-makers sometimes pick technically perfect solutions that are later rejected by staff. Involve your users from the start.

With this systematic approach, you’ll find a solution that meets your needs not just today, but five years from now as well.

Frequently Asked Questions

How secure are AI-based signature systems against hacker attacks?

Modern AI signature systems use multi-layered security: end-to-end encryption, zero-knowledge architectures, and isolated AI processing environments. Biometric data is stored not in plain text, but as irreversible hashes. Even in the event of a data leak, hackers cant reconstruct the original signatures. Leading vendors comply with security standards such as ISO 27001 and are regularly audited by independent security experts.

What if the AI mistakenly flags a genuine signature as a forgery?

False positives (genuine signatures flagged as forged) are extremely rare with modern systems (below 0.5%). Should it happen, professional solutions offer manual review workflows. A human expert can override the AI decision and retrain the system accordingly. For mission-critical processes, a four-eyes principle is recommended for all anomaly alerts from the AI.

Can employees trick the AI system with forged signatures?

Modern AI systems are far harder to deceive than human reviewers. They analyze over 100 biometric parameters that simply can’t be replicated manually. Dynamic features (writing speed, pressure curves, acceleration patterns) are virtually impossible to fake. In theory, only highly skilled counterfeiters with specialized equipment could fool the system—a level of effort that doesn’t pay off for standard business processes.

How long does implementation of an AI signature solution take?

Implementation time depends on your IT landscapes complexity. Basic cloud solutions without system integration can go live in 2–4 weeks. Complex on-premise installations with ERP, CRM, and DMS integrations typically take 8–16 weeks. Key factors are number of interfaces, customizations, and compliance testing. An experienced partner will draft a detailed project plan with milestones and fallback scenarios.

What legal risks are involved in using AI for signature recognition?

The main risk lies in incomplete GDPR compliance when processing biometric data. Ensure that explicit consent is collected and deletion periods are observed. For international business, be aware of varying legal frameworks—eIDAS in the EU, ESIGN Act in the USA, etc. Only use certified vendors and have your compliance team review contract terms. Getting legal advice up front can prevent expensive corrections later.

What are the ongoing costs of an AI signature solution?

Costs vary greatly depending on the model and usage volumes. SaaS solutions typically cost €15–50 per user/month or €0.50–3.00 per signature. On-premise licenses start at €25,000–75,000 plus 15–20% yearly maintenance. Add implementation (€5,000–50,000), training (€2,000–10,000), and any required hardware (€500–2,000 per workstation). With 1,000 signatures a month, TCO is typically €2,000–5,000 per month.

Does AI signature recognition work for illegible handwriting?

Yes—it can even work better with illegible signatures. AI systems dont analyze legibility as such, but focus on biometric features like writing dynamics, pressure distribution, and motion patterns. An “illegible” signature often has very unique, hard-to-forge traits. The system learns each person’s individual patterns and recognizes even extreme variations as authentic. Very simple marks (e.g., just a line) can be problematic, since there are fewer unique characteristics.

Can external partners and customers use the digital signature solution without installing software?

Yes, modern solutions offer browser-based signature processes without installation. Partners receive a secure link via email, open the document in their browser, and sign directly on their screen (desktop, tablet, or smartphone). The AI verification runs in the background on your servers. For those still preferring paper, hybrid workflows are available: they sign on paper, you scan the document, and the AI checks its authenticity automatically.

What happens to signature data if the provider goes bankrupt?

This risk should be covered contractually. Reputable vendors offer escrow services, with your data and source codes held by a neutral trustee. In the event of insolvency, you get access to your data and can migrate to another vendor. Check whether export to standard formats (PDF/A, XML) is possible. Well-funded cloud providers (Microsoft, Adobe, DocuSign) are at lower risk of insolvency than smaller niche suppliers.

How do I convince skeptical employees of the benefits of an AI signature solution?

Focus on practical work advantages—not the technology itself. Show how employees save time (no running around, no waiting for signatures, faster project approvals). Demonstrate higher security compared to manual checking, and emphasize that AI supports staff, not replaces them. Start with voluntary pilot groups and let positive feedback circulate. Training should be hands-on—real business scenarios, not theoretical demos. Always communicate transparently about privacy, and address concerns openly.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *